Expanding your business operations is exciting, but the decision to hire independent contractors vs employees is pivotal to your success.

You can weigh certain considerations like:

In most jurisdictions, employees have more legal protections than contractors. Therefore, misclassifying employees as contractors for short-term gains can result in penalties.
While independent contractors often provide hiring flexibility, employing full-time staff is desirable for a long-term commitment.
Full-time employees offer greater control and integration into your company culture, while contractors provide access to specialized skills without training.

Ultimately, international hiring is challenging due to multiple considerations regarding labor law compliance and tax obligations.

So, an Employer of Record (EOR) or Agent of Record (AOR) service plays a key role when hiring globally.

An EOR assumes legal and administrative liabilities of hiring employees in foreign markets, while an AOR excels in contractor management.

But when is hiring workers through such payroll & staffing platforms better?

Read along to explore scenarios where you should consider utilizing an EOR for hiring employees rather than contractors, providing insights into compliance, scalability, and long-term operational success.

Defining Contractors and Employees

The distinction between independent contractors and employees is decided based on crucial legal, tax, and operational purposes.

The classification of such workers is determined by several factors, including:

The degree of control you can employer exercise over the work schedule.
Whether the worker has a profit motive is independent of your control.
The degree to which the worker is integrated into your business.

The rule of thumb says that if you show excessive control over a worker's schedule, the worker is more likely to be classified as an employee.

Conversely, if you allow substantial freedom to control and operate independently, they are more likely to be classified as independent contractors.

Employers in the US can define contractor vs employee by understanding the difference between hiring 1099 contractors vs W2 employees.

Who is an Independent Contractor?

Contractors are self-employed individuals who provide services to businesses, whether project-based or contractual.

They have significant control over their work, including:

Contractors can set their own work hours and schedules.
They choose their methods and techniques for completing tasks.
Contractors often work remotely or from their own offices.

You can consider hiring independent contractors for scenarios like:

When you must complete a specific project or task within a limited timeframe.
If you require specialized skills or expertise that it doesn't have in-house.
To handle increased workload during busy periods without hiring full-time employees.
For creative or professional services that can be provided on a freelance basis.

Who is an Employee?

Workers under a formal employment agreement are known as employees.

They follow the company's policies and procedures and contribute to its goals and objectives.

In doing so, they are eligible for employee protection under statutory labor laws.

Employers are responsible for benefits administration, withholding taxes, and paying payroll taxes on employees' behalf.

You can utilize our salary insights for benchmarking.

Pros of Hiring Independent Contractors

When deciding independent contractors vs employees, you can choose to hire independent contractors for benefits like:

Access to expertise

You can source contractors from anywhere in the world and get access to a broader range of skills and expertise.
Moreover, contractors can bring specialized skills and expertise to your project without the long-term hiring commitment.

Flexibility and scalability

Most contractor categories provide the flexibility of hiring and firing without obliging to statutory termination procedures.
This allows you to adjust your workforce requirements per fluctuating business needs.
You can also hire independent contractors to evaluate potential candidates before transitioning them to full-time employees.

Cost savings

You can significantly reduce overheads as employer-sponsored benefits like insurance premiums or paid time off, and withholding taxes.
Long-term commitments like retirement plans, severance pay, etc, do not apply to most independent contractor classifications.
Moreover, contractors can address specific projects or tasks so that you can save training costs on your existing resources.

Cons of Hiring Independent Contractors

However, international hiring of independent contractors comes with potential drawbacks like less control over work & integration, misclassification risks, and challenges with intellectual property rights over the work product.

Let’s explore it further:

Legal and compliance risks

More often than not, you may misinterpret local labor laws and classify employees as independent contractors.
It makes you vulnerable to misclassifying risks like paying contractors back wages, extending statutory benefits, and paying employer taxes retrospectively in addition to various fines and penalties. It could be followed by reputational damage.

Intellectual property concerns

The legal consequences of improper contractor management may result in disputes over ownership of intellectual property created by the contractors.
Even though you may have limited liability protection, you must draft a contractual agreement covering confidentiality, trade secrets, copyrights, and patents before working with a contractor.

Less integration and commitment

In general, it can be more difficult to enforce contracts than employees.
Independent contractors usually have different work styles or communication preferences, which may lead to a daily culture mismatch.
Moreover, they do not contribute to knowledge transfer, which impacts your long-term growth.

Pros of Hiring Employees

Employing full-time staff between an employee and a contractor gives you better control, long-term commitment, and integration into company culture.

There is also a diminishing cost factor involved in hiring employees.

Let’s explore it further:

Control and consistency

You can directly supervise and standardize employees' work schedules for consistent output.
You can train your resources for long-term commitment and better integration into your company culture.

Loyalty and long-term commitment

Employees usually show loyalty and commitment to your business.
It benefits your business by reducing workforce churn, increasing productivity, and improving customer satisfaction.

Teamwork and collaboration

One critical difference between contractors and employees is that full-time employees can significantly contribute to a cohesive work environment.
Employees are effective in enhancing teamwork and innovation as they are more likely to align with company culture, show long-term commitment, and enable knowledge transfer.

Cons of Hiring Employees

However, employees in most jurisdictions are better protected with statutory rights.

It could increase your compliance burden due to the following factors:

Higher costs

Hiring and retaining full-time employees leads to a financial burden of salaries, including bonuses, overtime pay, and benefits like health insurance, accidental insurance, paid time off, and more.
Further, you must factor in training, infrastructure, and administrative expenses.

Legal and regulatory compliance

Labor law compliance related to minimum wage, termination, anti-discrimination, etc., can increase administration costs.
You must also oblige with tax obligations to withhold employee income taxes and contribute your share to the employee welfare scheme.
Moreover, US employers must comply with various tax and labor acts, such as the Federal Income Tax, Federal Insurance Contributions Act (FICA), Federal Unemployment Tax (FUTA), Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA), Occupational Safety and Health Act (OSHA), Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA), Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC), and more.

Performance management

Unlike simple contractor management, managing full-time employees requires dedicated Human Resource personnel in your team.
Your in-house HR teams will review compliance and track employee performance, adding to overall cost.

Factors to Consider in Worker Classification

Here’s a simple checklist to decide to hire an independent contractor vs employee and avoid misclassification risks:

Nature of work

The nature of work can influence whether a worker should be classified as an employee or contractor. Here’s how:

Factor	Contractor	Employee
Specialized skills	It gives you access to specialized skills or expertise	Most often rely on training to gain special skills
Duration of the relationship	Often a short-term, project-based relationship.	Typically, a long-term, ongoing relationship.
Profit motive	Workers are self-employed and seek to profit from their business or services, independent of the employer's control.	Worker's income primarily depends on the wages or salary that you provide.

Control and autonomy

The level of control over how work is performed can impact worker classification.

Here’s how:

Factor	Contractor	Employee
Control over work	You have limited control over their work schedule, methods, and location.	You can significantly control their work details, methods, and location.
Integration into the business	Worker operates with minimal integration into the employer's business.	Worker is integrated into your business, following its procedures and policies.
Intellectual Property (IP) rights	It is often challenging to enforce IP rights when engaging a contractor.	You have more control over workers’ IP rights created during the tenure.

Financial risk and investment

Here are some financial aspects of worker classification, including risk, investment, and profit potential:

Factor	Contractor	Employee
Risk	You face lower risk as the contractor is responsible for their taxes and liabilities.	You have higher risk due to statutory liability for employee actions, benefits, and taxes.
Investment	You require lower investment as contractors are paid on a project or hourly basis.	You will incur higher investment costs, including salary, statutory benefits, and overheads.
Profit Potential	Known to offer short-term cost savings and hiring flexibility.	May involve higher long-term costs but can lead to increased productivity and innovation.

You have the budget to fulfill statutory benefits: Employees often receive benefits such as health insurance, retirement plans, and paid time off.
You want to own intellectual property: Employees typically own the intellectual property they create while working for your company.

Tax Implications: Contractor vs Employee

Here’s a breakdown of employee vs contractor tax status.

Employment taxes

The table compares the tax obligations of independent contractors vs employers, including withholding, Social Security, and Medicare contributions:

Factor	Contractor	Employee
Income tax withholding	No income tax withholding is required.	You must withhold employee income to fulfill federal, state, or local tax obligations.
Payroll taxes	You are generally not required to provide benefits to contractors.	You pay towards social security and FUTA taxes, like health insurance, retirement plans, and paid time off.
1099 Forms	US employers must issue Form 1099-NEC to report contractor income.	Not required.
Employer matching contributions	There are no such requirements.	You must match the employee's Social Security and Medicare contributions.
Self-employment taxes	Applicable in some jurisdictions.	Not applicable

Tax reporting and compliance

US employers have different tax forms and reporting requirements for contractors vs employees. ‘

Here is a quick overview:

Form	Issued by	Receipt
Form 1099-NEC Reporting non-employee compensation paid to independent contractors	Employer	Independent Contractor
Schedule C Reporting self-employment income for contractors	Independent Contractor	IRS
Form W-2 Reporting wages, tips, and taxes withheld for employees	Employer	Employee
Form W-4 Indicating withholding allowances for federal income tax	Employee	Employer
Form 1099-MISC Reporting certain types of income paid to non-employees (less common for contractors)	Employer	Non-employee recipient

Legal implications and compliance

You must consider various legal factors, including misclassification risks, labor law compliance, intellectual property protection, data privacy, and immigration laws when deciding to hire between contractors vs employees.

Employment law considerations

Moreover, when hiring employees, you must fulfill statutory protections, such as minimum wage, overtime pay, and anti-discrimination measures.

Conversely, contractors have fewer legal protections in the workplace.

Here is a review of key employment laws in the US that apply to employees but not contractors:

Law	Purpose
Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA)	Sets minimum wage and overtime requirements.
Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA)	Provides unpaid leave for family or medical reasons.
Occupational Safety and Health Act (OSHA)	Ensures a safe and healthy workplace.
Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC)	Prohibits discrimination based on protected characteristics.
Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA)	Requires reasonable accommodations for employees with disabilities.
Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA)	Sets standards for employer-sponsored retirement plans.

Worker’s compensation and insurance

Here is an outline of insurance requirements for contractors vs employees:

Factor	Independent Contractors	Employees
Workers' Compensation	Not mandatory	Enforced by law
Other Insurance	Not applicable.	Typically includes health, life, and disability insurance.
Risk Assessment	Contractors are responsible for their own insurance needs.	You should assess the risks associated with the work.

Click here to read an overview of countries that offer universal free healthcare.

International Hiring Considerations

You must consider legal, tax, and cultural factors when hiring workers - independent contractor vs employee - outside your country:

Cross-border tax and legal compliance

There are country-specific criteria for employing someone as a full-time staff or an independent contractor.
- For instance, if the individual is a U.S. contractor, you may need to issue a 1099 form to report their income.
You may have to plan relocation assistance, such as housing or travel expenses for employees relocating to your country.
You must account for cultural differences in communication styles, holidays, and traditions that may affect work schedules.
Moreover, the time zone differences can impact communication and collaboration.

Employer of Record (EOR) & Agent of Record (AOR) Solutions

Employer of Record (EOR) and Agent of Record (AOR) solutions have emerged as a modern HR solution to solve the issues of cross-border tax and legal compliance:

EOR helps bypass the legal mandate to form a local entity and set up a physical space to hire employees.
EORs are great for international hiring, including visa and work permit applications, background checks, and onboarding.
EORs can free up your HR team and help you comply with labor law, especially regarding minimum wage, overtime rules, payroll taxes, social security contributions, employment termination procedures, and data privacy regulations.

You can rely on specialized AOR services to simplify contractor management tasks such as monitoring contractor hours worked, paying contractors and issuing 1099 forms annually to report their income, managing intellectual property rights, and more.

Conclusion

Skuad can be your global workforce management platform for onboarding and managing your international teams. We can help you operate quickly in new markets without establishing an entity.

Our EOR services minimize legal and administrative liabilities when hiring employees in over 160 countries.

Moreover, you can use Skuad’s AOR contractor management software for efficient contractor payroll & compliance.

Book a demo to learn more about how Skuad can customize support for hiring employees or contractors in your country of operation.

FAQs

1) Why do companies hire contractors instead of employees?

Companies hire contractors over employees for flexibility in managing & terminating workers, resulting in reduced overheads. Moreover, you get access to independent contractors’ specialized skills without providing training to your employees.

2) Is it better to have employees or 1099s?

Hiring employees generally provides greater control over the work but comes at higher costs and administrative burdens. Hiring independent contractors or 1099-per-IRS classification is more flexible and cost-effective. Subsequently, careful consideration of misclassification risks and liabilities is required.

3) What is the difference between a contractor and an employee?

The difference between contractors and employees is defined through legal interpretations of your control over workers' activities. You have more control over the work activities of employees than contractors. Typically, employees enjoy better employment rights, and you must extend statutory benefits.

4) How do you classify an employee vs a contractor?

You can classify an employee vs a contractor based on work schedule and applicable statutory employment rights and duties per local labor laws. An EOR service like Skuad can help avoid misclassification penalties in over 160 countries.

5) How does the IRS determine if a person is an independent contractor or an employee?

The IRS in the United States determines whether a worker is an independent contractor or an employee based on the following factors:

Behavioral control for supervision of their work schedule,
Financial control for pay schedule, tool/equipment reimbursement, and
Relationship between the parties to extend employment benefits.

Hire, pay and manage your talent in 160+ countries.

Contractors vs Employees: Pros and Cons for Employers

Table of Content

Building a remote team?